390 vs 309
Transition of Robbery laws to Section 309, maintaining the focus on violent theft.
What Changed?
Consolidation of IPC 390 to 392 into BNS 309.
Retainment of the specific 14-year penalty for nighttime highway robbery.
Verdict
"Consistent enforcement of severe penalties for violent street crimes and highway robberies."
Detailed Analysis
390
Section Data Pending
309
Section Data Pending
Legal Implications
Practical Scenarios
"A group stopping a truck on a highway at 2 AM and robbing the driver (BNS 309 - up to 14 years)."
"Forcibly taking a chain from a pedestrian after threatening them with a weapon (BNS 309)."
Expert Q&A
Is robbery bail-able under BNS?
No, Section 309 is non-bailable.
What is the highway robbery premium under Section 392/BNS 309?
Section 392 provides a maximum of 14 years RI for robbery on a road between sunset and sunrise — 4 years more than the standard 10-year maximum. This premium reflects the special vulnerability of travellers on isolated roads at night.
What is the difference between robbery (392) and dacoity (395)?
Only the number of participants. Two people robbing = robbery (Section 392, up to 10-14 years). Five or more people robbing = dacoity (Section 395, life imprisonment or 10 years).
What converts a theft into robbery?
Force or the threat of instant force — either (a) to commit the theft, (b) to facilitate escape after theft, or (c) to retain the stolen property. The moment a thief threatens or hits the victim, the offence escalates from theft (3 years) to robbery (10–14 years).
Deepen Your Legal Knowledge
Explore more side-by-side comparisons of the Indian Law reforms 2024. Detailed analysis for lawyers, students, and legal practitioners.
Explore All Comparisons